adventures in raw milk
Raw milk, aka unpasteurized milk, is so freaking delicious. I first sampled it a couple of years ago when I was in Ireland. I’ve never been a huge milk drinker. As a kid I was intolerant to cows milk and since then I’ve not really been one to drink a glass of milk. But when I tasted the deliciously creamy, earthy raw milk in my cup of coffee that first day in Dublin, I realized I love milk. Not the watery crap that passes for milk you buy at the supermarket, but real milk that is straight from the cow, filtered, chilled, and has a light golden hue from the grass the cows eat. Nothing else. In the short four days I was in Ireland I ate more dairy than I had in the previous month. My favorite was the Cashel blue cheese. Mmmmmm
So over the weekend, much to my delight, I was able to procure a gallon of fresh raw milk. After drinking a few glasses of yumminess, I decided to put the remainder of raw milk to use and make butter and yogurt.
Butter is easy, especially with a stand mixer. I skimmed the separated cream off the top of the room temperature milk and poured it into my handy dandy mixer, whisk attachment in. Whisk, whisk, whisk on high speed for about 10 minutes and voilà! BUTTER!

The cream is starting to break here.

The butter separates from the whey. Pull the butter out, form it together and wash it off.

Mmmmm … fresh butter. At this point you could add salt, but I prefer not to. Now all I need is to make some fresh bread to go with this delicious butter.
Next, I made yogurt with the remaining milk. I know there are precise ways and temperature settings in making yogurt at home, as well as all sorts of fancy machines, but I make it in the simple way my mom and my grandmother taught me. Not once have we ever been sickened or has the yogurt not turned out. That being said, use this method at your own risk.
- First pour the gallon of room temperature milk into a very clean deep metal pot.
- Heat the milk on medium-high heat until it just starts to bubble up. Do not bring it to a full boil. Turn off the heat and let the milk sit to cool. If you have an electric range, pull the pot off the burner. Let the milk cool just until you can stick your finger in without it burning (yes I know, very scientific). The milk should still be warm.
- Next put a heaping spoonful (2-3 tbsp) of your previous batch of yogurt into the warm milk and mix in thoroughly. Use a very clean metal or plastic spoon. I currently have some organic yogurt left that my mom made a few weeks ago that I used. You can get a small container of your favorite yogurt at the store to get started if you don’t have any at home, or you can purchase some powdered yogurt starter at health food stores. Just follow the directions on the package.
- Pour the warm mixture into a larger container (or several small ones) that seal tight.
- Cover the container(s) with some dish towels so no light can get in and put them in a cool corner of your kitchen. Let this sit for 24 hours.
- The next day put your yogurt into the fridge to cool. Once cooled open up your containers of fully set delicious yogurt and taste. There might be some whey at the top. You can either mix this back in or pour it off, whichever you prefer. It should have a shelf life of at least 3 weeks, though mine lasts over a month.

These are the bubbles you see when it just starts to boil.

Yay, homemade yogurt! All this needs is some of the fresh strawberries and blackberries I just got at the farmer’s market. Yum.
With my next gallon of raw milk I’m making fresh mozzarella. Stay tuned …